The results are in on the first-ever Critics’ Choice Television Awards, and while they didn’t quite live up to the promise of those heady early hours, where it seemed like all the underdogs would finally have their day, you can’t fault most of these. Yes, for all their hype as another new alternative to the Emmys, they picked a lot of old familiars—Mad Men, Modern Family, The Daily Show, Jim Parsons, Tina Fey—which, as good as those shows and most of those people are, isn’t all that exciting. But hey, they recognized John Noble’s even-more-outstanding-than-usual work on this past season of Fringe, hopefully paved the way for more trophies to come for Justified’s Margo Martindale, and after many years of Emmy nominations, Neil Patrick Harris finally got an award for How I Met Your Mother. Plus, Dirty Jobs’ Mike Rowe now has something to show for all the times he flopped around in pig shit and stuff. Here’s the complete list of winners. [via TV Line]

Best Drama Series: Mad Men

Best Comedy Series: Modern Family

Best Talk Show: The Daily Show With Jon Stewart

Best Reality Series: (TIE) Hoarders and The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills

Best Reality Series Competition: American Idol

Lead Actor In A Drama: Jon Hamm, Mad Men

Lead Actress In A Drama: Julianna Marguiles, The Good Wife

Supporting Actor In A Drama: John Noble, Fringe

Supporting Actress In A Drama: (TIE) Margo Martindale, Justified and Christina Hendricks, Mad Men


Lead Actor In A Comedy: Jim Parsons, The Big Bang Theory

Lead Actress In A Comedy: Tina Fey, 30 Rock

Supporting Actor In A Comedy: Neil Patrick Harris, How I Met Your Mother

Supporting Actress In A Comedy: Busy Phillips, Cougar Town

Best Reality Host: Mike Rowe, Dirty Jobs

Television Icon Award: Danny DeVito