After Naomi Grossman’s Pepper became the first character to return and link the worlds of American Horror Story: Asylum and American Horror Story: Freak Show, Entertainment Weekly reports that Lily Rabe will also reprise her Asylum role as Sister Mary Eunice. Rabe, who’s appeared in every season of AHS so far, will join the Freak Show cast in the 10th episode “winter cliffhanger,” where she’ll help explain how Pepper left the freak show’s company and ended up in Briarcliff. She’ll also remind viewers of that time when Sister Mary Eunice was just a sweet nun, before she became possessed by the devil.

Advertisement