TV Reviews1/10/21Jan 10SaveTV Reviews1/10/21C+TV ReviewsThe arrival of real villains on Shameless highlights the messy heroism of the GallaghersMyles McNutt20One of the central tenets of Shameless is the fact that our “heroes,” as it were, often act in ways that would…
TV Reviews12/28/20Dec 282TV Reviews12/28/20B-TV ReviewsAn improved second season of His Dark Materials stumbles a bit at the finish lineMyles McNutt109In the opening scenes of “Æsahættr,” we reunite with Ruta Skadi, who wakes up on a random cliffside and overhears a…
TV Reviews12/21/20Dec 21SaveTV Reviews12/21/20BTV ReviewsAfter elevating its storytelling, His Dark Materials has a bit of a letdown in the season's penultimate hourMyles McNutt34The last two episodes of His Dark Materials have been the strongest thus far because they have isolated story…
TV Reviews12/20/20Dec 20SaveTV Reviews12/20/20B-TV ReviewsLook, we're also shocked Frank is the most interesting part of this week's ShamelessMyles McNutt20For the first few episodes of Shameless’ final season, I’ve been waiting for the show to start acting like it’s…
TV Reviews12/14/20Dec 14SaveTV Reviews12/14/20A-TV ReviewsHis Dark Materials cuts a new window into Coulter's worldview in another standout episodeMyles McNutt48“The Scholar” is, from a plot perspective, an important turning point in the journey of our three heroes who seem…
Best Of12/14/20Dec 143Best Of12/14/20Best OfThe 25 best TV shows of 2020Danette Chavez, Erik Adams, Patrick Gomez, and 12 more226In a year that saw many of us relegated to our homes for much of its duration, TV was an ever more powerful medium…
TV Reviews12/13/20Dec 13SaveTV Reviews12/13/20C+TV ReviewsShameless continues to test the viability of a no-stakes final seasonMyles McNutt23On a macro level, the absence of stakes is one of the (many) problems plaguing Shameless entering its final season.…
TV Reviews12/7/20Dec 7SaveTV Reviews12/7/20A-TV ReviewsThe introduction of the Subtle Knife is His Dark Materials' finest hour so farMyles McNutt75The Golden Compass, the 2007 film that failed to turn His Dark Materials into a fantasy film franchise, was clearly…
TV Reviews12/6/20Dec 6SaveTV Reviews12/6/20CTV ReviewsA pandemic-fueled premiere suggests Shameless is still content to limp to the finish line in its final seasonMyles McNutt33The opening scene of the Shameless pilot, which debuted almost a decade ago in 2011, introduces us to the Gallagher…
TV Reviews11/30/20Nov 30SaveTV Reviews11/30/20BTV ReviewsDaddy issues multiply in His Dark Materials’ land of daemons and dustMyles McNutt60NOTE: While The A.V. Club’s coverage of His Dark Materials looked at the first season from both Expert and Newbie …
TV Reviews11/23/20Nov 232TV Reviews11/23/20B-TV ReviewsA muddled Magisterium raises doubts about His Dark Materials’ commitment to its source materialMyles McNutt40NOTE: While The A.V. Club’s coverage of His Dark Materials looked at the first season from both Expert and Newbie…
TV Reviews11/16/20Nov 16SaveTV Reviews11/16/20BTV ReviewsHis Dark Materials follows its characters into a new world, but the story's much the same (for better or worse)Myles McNutt49By the time a television adaptation of a book series reaches its second season, it needs to feel as though it can…
For Our Consideration6/22/20Jun 221For Our Consideration6/22/20For Our ConsiderationEven before moving from Disney+ to Hulu, Love, Victor had little to add to queer televisionMyles McNutt60In the opening scene of Love, Victor, the show’s eponymous protagonist writes an angry Instagram DM to Simon Spier,…
TV Reviews4/1/20Apr 1SaveTV Reviews4/1/20B-TV ReviewsYes, we’re still complaining about Edge of Extinction as Survivor’s winners season makes the mergeMyles McNutt42The idea of “making it to the merge” is one of Survivor’s most universal narratives. No matter what season you’re…
TV Reviews2/12/20Feb 122TV Reviews2/12/20A-TV ReviewsWinners go to War as Survivor delivers a thrilling start to its (overstuffed) 40th seasonMyles McNutt59Last week, ahead of Survivor’s fortieth—that is not a typo, it airs two seasons a year—season premiere, CBS aired a…
TV Reviews1/26/20Jan 26 2020SaveTV Reviews1/26/20B+TV ReviewsGallavich is hitched at last, but the state of Shameless means the final season likely won't be a honeymoonMyles McNutt42When the credits rolled on “Gallavich!,” the tenth and penultimate season finale of Shameless’ run on Showtime, it…
TV Reviews1/19/20Jan 19 2020SaveTV Reviews1/19/20D+TV ReviewsWhile Shameless has been a disappointment all season, its penultimate episode is just plain badMyles McNutt50Last week’s episode of Shameless ended on a pivotal emotional moment: Lip, realizing that the best path forward for…
TV Reviews1/12/20Jan 12 2020SaveTV Reviews1/12/20B-TV ReviewsAn offer and a proposal promise change for Shameless and the Gallagher familyMyles McNutt19Early in “Now Leaving Illinois,” Liam is called into the office at school: he’s been flagged as a potential…
TV Reviews1/5/20Jan 5 2020SaveTV Reviews1/5/20B-TV ReviewsIsolated moments of family connection keep Shameless from going entirely off the railsMyles McNutt15Ever since the writers decided to give Carl and Debbie—and then Liam—their own storylines, Shameless has suffered…
TV Reviews12/29/19Dec 29 2019SaveTV Reviews12/29/19B-TV ReviewsShameless finally tries to fill the Fiona-sized hole at its center by leaning into GallavichMyles McNutt17Although we can argue about the effectiveness of many of Fiona’s stories over the course of Shameless’ first nine…